New England City Dubbed ‘America’s Filing Cabinet’ Is the Hottest Housing Market

Renowned as the “insurance capital of the world” and “America’s filing cabinet” due to its high concentration of insurer headquarters, Hartford, CT, has reclaimed the title of America’s hottest housing market after more than a year.

The quintessential New England metro, which encompasses the cities of Hartford, West Hartford, and East Hartford, has emerged as a magnet for buyers seeking relative affordability compared with the region’s high-priced, fiercely competitive and inventory-starved real estate markets of Boston and New York City.

Buoyed by rising demand from shoppers looking for a better value within commuting distance from these larger metros, Hartford climbed four spots year over year in the Realtor.com® May Hottest Markets report to clinch the top spot, dethroning April’s leader, Springfield, MA, which finished fifth.

The Realtor.com market hotness rankings are based on two metrics: 1) market demand, as measured by unique views per property on Realtor.com and 2) the pace of the market reflected in the number of days a listing remains active on the platform.

In May, Hartford attracted 5.3 times the national average number of viewers per property, the highest ratio in the entire top 20. The typical home there sold in just 25 days, five days faster than a year ago and nearly a month faster than the national norm.

Realtor.com senior economist Hannah Jones says the surging demand and swift market pace together reflect Hartford’s highly restricted supply of for-sale homes and more buyer-friendly conditions compared with its larger and pricier neighbors.

In fact, at a median listing price of $475,000, Hartford is significantly more accessible than either Boston or New York, where asking prices in May registered at $849,000 and $775,000, respectively.

“In the post-COVID era, what people have been looking for in a home had evolved, and that has lead to people heading to Hartford from more dense metros like Boston and New York,” Carl Lantz, a West Hartford-based real estate agent at Coldwell Banker Realty, tells Realtor.com. “Despite the great increases in prices, and owners’ home equity, we are still a better value than both of those areas.”

However, Lantz says Hartford’s growing appeal is a double-edged sword, as the market suffers from a critical shortage of listings. Based on Realtor.com data analysis, Hartford’s current inventory is 75% below its pre-pandemic norms.

“We absolutely do not have the needed inventory, even to support the normal move-up, move-down local buyers,” says the agent. “That lack of inventory has been the prime driver of prices, and it’s not an easy fix.”

Lantz argues that building new homes takes time and money—a challenge that calls for a multipronged approach combining incentives for developing workforce housing, adding accessory dwelling units, and providing aid to first-time and low-income buyers.

There is much more to Hartford than relatively affordable real estate and insurance companies. Founded in 1635 by English settlers, Hartford is among the oldest U.S. cities boasting several premier cultural landmarks, including the Connecticut State Capitol, the historic homes of celebrated 19th century authors Mark Twain and Harriet Beecher Stowe, and the Wadsworth Atheneum Museum of Art, the nation’s oldest public art museum.  

On top of that, the metro offers vibrant shopping, dining, and outdoor spaces, including easy access to beaches and mountains.

For home shoppers coming from outside the area, Lantz reminds that Greater Hartford has in store a wide variety of communities to choose from, ranging from the bustling cities of Hartford and West Hartford to more rural Glastonbury and Farmington Valley.

“For buyers who feel like they want to wait and save more, I remind them that the market is still moving upwards here, and if they find a home they like now, those increases will be theirs in the next year, but not if they don’t purchase now,” says the agent. “Prices will likely be higher again next year, so their purchasing power might be diminished in the future.”

Northeast tightens its grip on ranking

For the last two and a half years, the Northeast and Midwest have been the only two regions represented on the top 20 hottest markets list, but recently the Northeast has pulled ahead to cement its dominance.

In May, 15 of the 20 hottest markets were in the Northeast, with Connecticut alone claiming five spots in the rankings, and New England accounting for the majority of the top 10, including Amherst Town-Northampton, MA, and Springfield, MA.

However, Jones stresses that the metros on the list reflect a wide variety of price points and buyer profiles, from $330,000 in Rochester, NY, to $847,000 in Bridgeport, CT, signaling that the spillover demand from NYC and Boston is broad and not limited to just affordable markets.

“Until inventory expands meaningfully in the region’s supply-constrained markets, the Northeast’s grip on this list is unlikely to loosen,” predicts Jones.

The common thread uniting all 20 hottest markets—and fueling intense competition among buyers—is drastically low inventory. In most instances, markets are 50% or more below their pre-pandemic levels.

On the other hand, metros that have seen steady listing growth, such as Concord, NH, and Manchester-Nashua, NH, are experiencing a more relaxed market pace that gives buyers more breathing room to make a decision. 

“Even so, ‘more inventory’ in these markets is a relative term; they remain deeply supply-constrained by any historical standard,” adds Jones.

As the housing market moves into the summer, buyers in smaller, relatively budget-friendly metros are advised to get their financing in order and be prepared to move quickly.

For sellers in the hottest markets, limited inventory and intense demand offer meaningful advantages, but Jones says they should price realistically from the outset to make the most of the current market conditions.